Which OS Is Ideal for You? Windows 7, Vista or XP?

The answer depends on more than you might think. Just because Windows Vista is the newest full version available doesn’t automatically make it the perfect fit. Similarly, Windows 7 is the most flexible Microsoft OS (operating system) to date, but some users will have ample reason to stick with Vista or Windows XP until Windows 7 is on store shelves. A lot depends on what you are using your computer for and on which type of computer you’re using. Gamers, media authors, travel-inclined business people and casual web surfers all have different priorities and will want to choose OSs accordingly.

We’ve provided a brief outline of the basic features and key uses of Windows 7, Vista and Windows XP to give you an idea of which OS is right for you. More detailed information about each of the Windows versions can be found in our hands on reviews above.


Microsoft Windows 7


While currently in beta phase, Windows 7 already looks to have righted many of the wrongs of Vista. This is particularly true in terms of a smooth release. Windows 7 is slated for release in mid to late 2009. Judging by the current quality and usability of the Windows 7 Beta, we’re confident that end users will experience a smooth transition to the OS when it hits store shelves. The fresh interface and look of Windows 7 are welcome changes, especially compared to the more resource-hungry and less innovative operation of Vista.

Key features include:

• Plug and play capability with hardware and peripheral devices
• Completely customizable task bar
• Jump lists
• Homegroup networking
• Low memory footprint


Vista


Microsoft will never fully own up to just how bumpy Vista’s release was. The young debutante Vista was demanding, awkward and aggravating. But just because Vista was a failure at release doesn’t mean it was a bad operating system. With Microsoft’s continued patching and the release of the Vista Service Pack 1, the OS matured into a highly functional, if resource-hungry, interface ideal for most users. Many users will be comfortable using Vista well after Windows 7 is available.

Key features include:

• Windows Media Center
• Advanced protection from malware
• Parental control options
• Windows sidebar
• Real time searches
 

Windows XP


Despite the fact that XP has been around for years, it is relatively forgiving on older machines and netbooks. XP continues to have a great reputation amongst gamers due to its low impact idling and compatibility with both old and new programs. Users with specific multimedia demands that don’t want to upgrade their hardware will find XP an appealing alternative to the more demanding Vista. While XP will no longer be sold after the release of Windows 7, Microsoft has committed to providing support for the OS until 2014.

Key features include:

• Fast boot up time
• Driver rollback
• Low system requirements
• Low memory footprint


What to Look for in a Windows Operating System?


When considering a new Windows operating system it is most important to think about how you intend to use the computer. After deciding your computer's primary function, you will need to decide what kind of networking and administrations tools you need and the level of security you desire

Below are the criteria TopTenREVIEWS used to evaluate Windows Operating Systems:

Home and Office Use
We assessed the operating system in terms of how well it supports general home use; for example, it should have basic Internet security and be easy to use. OSs for office or business use need sophisticated Internet security, the capacity to network and ought to include administration tools.

Multimedia Use
Some OSs are designed to entertain, these can play/record television, burn DVDs,  and can support HD video and music without supplementary software.

Security
All OSs should provide frequently updated security features such as firewalls, pop-up blockers, antivirus and antispyware software and more. OSs for business or network use require additional security and administrator tools.

Networking
Business and home OSs can be used in a network. These systems should offer administration tools and security.

Ease of Use
All OSs should be straightforward; we looked at its search functions and more to rate the ease of use.

Technical Help/Support
Since OSs perform numerous functions, above average support is needed. Generally, Microsoft offers more support choices to its business customers and mostly self-guided support for individuals.

On this site, you’ll find articles related to operating systems, as well as comprehensive reviews and a side–by–side comparison to help you make an informed decision on which Windows Operating System is right for you. At TopTenREVIEWS We Do the Research So You Don’t Have To.™

 
TopTenREVIEWS
Become A Reviewer
Windows Operating System Main Image
 

Windows Operating System Review 

Windows Operating Systems in a Micro-Nut Shell

Depending on what type of computer you're using, you're probably considering making the leap to Windows 7, continuing with Vista or sticking with Windows XP. So which version of Windows is right for you?

Rank #1#2#3#4#5#6
Excellent score   Excellent
Very good score   Very Good
Good score   Good
Fair score   Fair
Poor score   Poor
Vista XP Home XP Media Center XP Professional XP Professional x64 XP Tablet PC Edition
Vista XP Home XP Media Center XP Professional XP Professional x64 XP Tablet PC Edition
Reviewer Comments Read Review
Read Review
Read Review
Read Review
Read Review
Read Review
Lowest Price Buy Vista
$99.95
Buy XP Home SP2
$237.99
Buy XP Media Center Update Rollup 2
$119.99
Buy XP Professional SP2
$264.99
Buy XP Professional x64
$149.99
Buy XP Tablet PC Edition 2005
$160.99
 
Overall Rating Excellent Very Good Very Good Excellent Very Good Very Good
Ratings
Home and Office Use Excellent Good Fair Excellent Excellent Very Good
Multimedia Excellent Good Excellent Fair Fair Fair
Security Excellent Very Good Very Good Excellent Excellent Excellent
Networking Excellent Fair Fair Excellent Excellent Excellent
Ease of Use Good Very Good Excellent Very Good Very Good Very Good
Technical Help/Support Very Good Excellent Good Excellent Excellent Good
View Specifications Go! Go! Go! Go! Go! Go!
View Screenshots View Vista screenshots View XP Home screenshots View XP Media Center screenshots View XP Professional screenshots View XP Professional x64 screenshots View XP Tablet PC Edition screenshots
Media/Entertainment Features
Media Player Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Media Center Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark  
Photo Editor/ Slideshow Check Mark   Check Mark    
Syncs to Portable Devices Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark  
Supports Xbox 360 Access to Files Check Mark   Check Mark    
Plug and Play Gaming Controls Available Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark    
DVD and CD Burning Software Check Mark      
Security Features
Internet Connection Firewall Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Antivirus Software Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Download Manager Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Malicious Software Removal Tool Check Mark      
Parental Controls Check Mark      
User-Level Access Control Check Mark    Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
IEEE 802.1x Security Protocol Check Mark    Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
File Encryption System Check Mark    Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Adjustable User Account Control       
Networking Features
Simple Networking Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Networking Wizards Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Roaming User Profiles Check Mark    Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Network Diagnostics Check Mark      
Administration Tools Check Mark      
Language Support Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Mobile Features
Battery Life Enhancements Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Saves Online Files for Offline Use Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Detects/Connects to Wireless Access Points Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Adjusts to Static or Dynamic IP Addresses Automatically Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Other Features
Backward Compatible   Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark  
Software Installation and Maintenance Check Mark    Check Mark Check Mark  
Automatically Adjusts to Hardware Check Mark      
Backup and Restore Center Check Mark      
Speech Recognition/ Voice Control Check Mark      Check Mark
Tablet PC Support Check Mark      Check Mark
Windows Marketplace       
Jump Lists       
System Requirements
Processing Speed 800 MHz 233 MHz 800 MHz 233 MHz   
RAM 512* MB 128 MB 512 MB 128 MB   
Hard Disk Space 15 GB 15 GB 15 GB 15 GB   
Technical Help/Support
Remote Assistance Check Mark Check Mark   Check Mark Check Mark  
Telephone Support Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
System Restore Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark Check Mark
Troubleshooting   Check Mark   Check Mark Check Mark  
Set-up Wizard Check Mark   Check Mark    Check Mark
Device Driver Rollback   Check Mark   Check Mark Check Mark  
How-To/Tutorials Check Mark Check Mark   Check Mark Check Mark  
Automatic Updates Check Mark Check Mark   Check Mark Check Mark  
 
Reviewer Comments Read Review
Read Review
Read Review
Read Review
Read Review
Read Review
Lowest Price Buy Vista
$99.95
Buy XP Home SP2
$237.99
Buy XP Media Center Update Rollup 2
$119.99
Buy XP Professional SP2
$264.99
Buy XP Professional x64
$149.99
Buy XP Tablet PC Edition 2005
$160.99

Ask & Answer

Type your question below and put your question in front of our entire community of users and experts.

Think You're a Guru?

Answer Questions
Visit our Ask & Answer Center to answer Questions.
Ads by Google